Best For: Anyone prioritizing safety and faster blade stops
Includes: Tool Only (bare tool)
Price: $187
- Best For: Save $53, don't mind longer coast time
- Includes: Tool Only (bare tool)
- Price: $134
Introduction
If you’re stuck choosing between the Makita XAG04Z vs XAG09Z, you’re not alone. These two cordless angle grinders look almost identical, and honestly, they ARE nearly twins. But there’s one key difference that could save your life on the job site.
Let me cut through the marketing fluff and tell you exactly what separates these two tools – because everything else is just noise.
Table of Contents
Quick Verdict:
The Makita XAG09Z wins at $187 with its electric brake (stops wheel in 2 seconds) and Active Feedback Technology safety features. The XAG04Z costs $134 but lacks the brake—wheel coasts for 8-10 seconds after release.
Related Articles:
At-a-glance Specs: Makita XAG04Z vs XAG09Z
| Features | XAG09Z 🏆 | XAG04Z |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $139 | $119 |
| Max Speed | 8,500 RPM | 8,500 RPM |
| Electric Brake | Yes (2-second stop) ✓ | No (8-10 second coast) |
| AFT Safety | Yes (auto-shutoff) ✓ | No |
| Anti-Restart | Yes ✓ | No |
| Auto Speed Change | Yes ✓ | Yes ✓ |
| Weight | 5.7 lbs (with battery) | 5.6 lbs (with battery) |
| Overall Rating | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐(4.9/5) | ⭐⭐⭐⭐(4.6/5) |
Why XAG09Z Is the Better Buy?
The XAG09Z’s safety features justify the $57 premium for most users, especially professionals working daily.
1. Electric Brake Stops Wheel in 2 Seconds
The XAG09Z includes an electric brake that stops the wheel in 2 seconds or less when you release the switch. The XAG04Z has no brake—the wheel coasts for 8-10 seconds before stopping completely.
Why this matters:
- Productivity: Move to next cut faster without waiting for wheel to stop
- Safety: Fewer accidental contact injuries during blade coast-down
- Blade changes: Swap blades immediately instead of waiting
According to Amazon reviews, professional fabricators and metal workers specifically praise the electric brake for reducing downtime between cuts. When making 50+ cuts per day, those 6-8 seconds per cut add up to significant time savings.
2. Active Feedback Technology (AFT) Auto-Shutoff
The XAG09Z features Active Feedback-sensing Technology that turns the motor off if rotation of the wheel is suddenly forced to stop. This protects you from kickback injuries when the wheel binds in a cut.
The XAG04Z lacks this safety feature—if the wheel binds, the motor keeps trying to spin, increasing kickback force.
AFT is particularly valuable when:
- Cutting through rebar-embedded concrete
- Working with metal that can pinch the blade
- Making plunge cuts where binding is more likely
- Operating in awkward positions where control is harder
3. Anti-Restart Protection
The XAG09Z won’t start if you insert a battery while the switch is locked on. The XAG04Z will immediately spin up—a potential safety hazard if the grinder is sitting on your workbench or in your lap.
This prevents the common scenario: grinder on workbench, switch locked on, insert battery, wheel immediately starts spinning and jumps off bench.
Real User Feedback
Based on Amazon review analysis:
- XAG09Z: 4.7/5 stars from 2,900+ verified buyers
- XAG04Z: 4.7/5 stars from 3,400+ verified buyers
Common praise for XAG09Z: “electric brake is a game-changer,” “AFT saved me from serious injury,” “worth every penny over the 04,” “blade stops instantly”
Common praise for XAG04Z: “great value for DIY use,” “plenty of power for occasional work,” “lighter on the wallet”
The ratings are identical, but XAG09Z reviews emphasize safety features while XAG04Z reviews focus on value.
When XAG04Z Makes Sense?
The XAG04Z costs $57 less and delivers identical cutting power. For certain users, skipping the safety features makes financial sense.
Choose XAG04Z if:
- Best For: Save $53, don't mind longer coast time
- Includes: Tool Only (bare tool)
- Price: $134
- You grind/cut less than once per month
- You’re extremely budget-conscious ($57 matters)
- You primarily do light DIY projects (cutting tile, thin metal)
- You’re patient waiting 8-10 seconds for wheel coast-down
- You already practice excellent safety habits
At $134, it handles all the same materials as the XAG09Z—concrete, tile, metal, pipe, conduit. The power output is identical. You’re just missing the safety conveniences.
Upgrade to XAG09Z when:
- Best For: Anyone prioritizing safety and faster blade stops
- Includes: Tool Only (bare tool)
- Price: $187
- You use a grinder weekly or more
- You work professionally (contractors, fabricators, mechanics)
- You cut demanding materials (rebar, thick steel, hard tile)
- The 2-second blade stop appeals to you
- Safety features matter in your work environment
Quick Buying Decision: 2 Questions
1. How often will you use it?
- Weekly or more, professional use → XAG09Z (safety features pay for themselves)
- Monthly or less, light DIY → XAG04Z (save $57, sufficient for occasional use)
2. Is $57 a dealbreaker?
- Can spend $187? → [GET XAG09Z – Electric brake + AFT safety →]
- Need to stay under $134? → [GET XAG04Z – Same power, less features →]
Detailed Specs (Nearly Identical)
Power & Performance:
- Both: 8,500 RPM no-load speed
- Both: Brushless motors (50% longer runtime vs brushed)
- Both: Automatic Speed Change technology (adjusts torque/speed under load)
- Both: 18V LXT battery system
- Both: Accepts 4-1/2″ and 5″ wheels
Safety Features:
- XAG09Z: Electric brake (2-second stop) ✓
- XAG09Z: Active Feedback Technology (AFT) ✓
- XAG09Z: Anti-restart protection ✓
- XAG04Z: Soft start ✓
- XAG04Z: None of the above
Physical Specs:
- XAG09Z: 5.7 lbs with battery, 14-1/4″ long
- XAG04Z: 5.6 lbs with battery, 14-1/4″ long
- Both: Rubberized soft grip
- Both: 3-stage LED battery gauge
- Both: Slide switch with lock-on
- Both: Tool-less wheel guard adjustment
Features:
- Both: Star Protection (prevents overload/over-discharge/overheating)
- Both: Spiral bevel gears for smooth operation
- Both: Wire mesh intake covers
- Both: Labyrinth construction (seals motor from dust/debris)
Battery Runtime (with 5.0Ah battery, approximate):
- Both: 40-50 minutes continuous grinding
- Both: 25-35 cutting passes through 1/4″ steel
- Identical efficiency due to same motor/electronics
Warranty:
- Both: Makita 3-year limited warranty
- Both: 1-year free service contract
- Both: 30-day satisfaction guarantee
Best Use Cases
XAG09Z Excels At:
- Professional metal fabrication (frequent cuts, blade changes)
- Concrete cutting with potential for blade binding
- Job sites with strict safety requirements
- Overhead work where kickback is more dangerous
- High-volume projects (50+ cuts per day)
- Working around other people
XAG04Z Excels At:
- Occasional DIY tile cutting
- Weekend home improvement projects
- Light metal work (thin stock, infrequent use)
- Budget-conscious tool collection building
- Learning angle grinder use
Both Handle Equally:
- Cutting tile and concrete
- Grinding welds smooth
- Cutting metal pipe and conduit
- Surface preparation
- Rust removal
- Sharpening mower blades
- General workshop tasks
Price Breakdown: Is $57 Worth It?
Note: The prices can vary depending upon the offers and sale on Amazon. You can even find XAG09Z at less price then XAG04Z.
XAG04Z at $134:
- Full grinding and cutting capability
- Automatic Speed Change technology
- Brushless motor efficiency
- Best if: Budget is tight, light use only
XAG09Z at $157:
- Everything XAG04Z has, plus:
- Electric brake (6-8 seconds saved per cut)
- AFT kickback protection
- Anti-restart safety
- Best if: Regular use, professional work, value safety
The math for professionals:
- Make 50 cuts per day
- Save 6 seconds per cut with electric brake
- That’s 5 minutes saved daily
- 25 minutes saved per week
- 20+ hours saved per year
The brake pays for itself in saved time within months of professional use.
For DIYers: If you use the grinder monthly, the $57 difference is roughly $6 per year over 10 years. Worth it for the safety peace of mind.
Kit Options Available
XAG04T Kit:
- XAG04Z grinder
- One 5.0Ah battery
- Rapid charger
- Tool bag
- Price: ~$239-259
XAG09Z:
- Sold as bare tool only (no kit version currently available)
- Must purchase battery/charger separately if needed
If you don’t own Makita 18V batteries yet and want the XAG09Z, budget for:
- XAG09Z: $187
- 5.0Ah battery: $60-80
- Rapid charger: $40-60
- Total: ~$287-377
Or consider the XAG04T kit at similar price and upgrade to XAG09Z later.
Bottom Line: Which Should You Buy?
- Best For: Anyone prioritizing safety and faster blade stops
- Includes: Tool Only (bare tool)
- Price: $187
For most users: The Makita XAG09Z at $187 delivers electric brake, AFT safety, and anti-restart protection worth the $57 premium over the XAG04Z. The 2-second blade stop alone justifies the difference for anyone using a grinder regularly.
On a tight budget or light use only? The XAG04Z at $134 provides identical grinding power and handles all the same materials. You’re trading safety conveniences for $57 savings.
Honestly: If you can afford the extra $57, get the XAG09Z. The electric brake becomes more valuable the more you use it, and the AFT safety feature could prevent a serious injury. Better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it.
Pro Tip: Professional fabricators and contractors report the electric brake is the single most appreciated feature on the XAG09Z. That instant blade stop makes rapid-fire cutting projects dramatically more efficient and less frustrating.
FAQs
Is the grinding power really identical?
Yes. According to manufacturer specs, both deliver 8,500 RPM and use the same brushless motor design with Automatic Speed Change technology. Cutting and grinding performance is indistinguishable—the difference is purely in safety features after you release the trigger.
How much longer does the XAG04Z coast without a brake?
User reports indicate 8-10 seconds for complete wheel stop on the XAG04Z. The XAG09Z stops in 2 seconds or less due to the electric brake. That’s a 6-8 second difference per trigger release.
Does the electric brake affect battery life?
Negligibly. The brake uses minimal energy to stop the wheel. Real-world battery runtime is essentially identical between both models according to user testing.
What is Active Feedback Technology exactly?
AFT monitors motor rotation and automatically shuts off power if the wheel suddenly binds or stops. This reduces kickback force and protects you from loss-of-control injuries. It’s like ABS brakes for your grinder.
Can I add an electric brake to the XAG04Z?
No. The brake is integrated into the motor and electronic control system. You’d need to buy the XAG09Z to get this feature.
Which one do professionals use?
According to Amazon reviews and tool forum discussions, professionals overwhelmingly choose the XAG09Z. The electric brake and AFT safety features matter more when you’re making hundreds of cuts per week. The $57 premium is insignificant compared to the time savings and injury prevention.
Is the XAG04Z unsafe?
No—it’s a quality grinder that meets safety standards. It just lacks the advanced safety features of the XAG09Z. Millions of grinders operate without electric brakes. The XAG09Z simply offers enhanced safety for $57 more.
