Price: $149
Introduction
Look, I get it. You’re standing there looking at the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z, and they look like twins. Same sleek body, same circular saw design, same Makita quality everyone talks about. So what’s the real difference? And more importantly, which one should you actually buy?
I’ve spent hours digging into these two models, and I’m going to save you the headache. By the end of this article, you’ll know exactly which saw belongs in your toolbox.
Table of Contents
Quick Verdict:
The Makita XSH04ZB wins – and it’s not even close.
Here’s why: it’s $70 cheaper ($149 vs $219), and here’s the kicker – it performs almost identically to the XSH03Z. Unless you absolutely need the specific features of the XSH03Z (which most people don’t), you’re basically paying extra for bragging rights.
But let me break down everything so you can decide for yourself.
Related Articles:
- Makita 5477NB vs 5377MG!
- Makita DSS611Z vs DHS680Z!
- Makita HS0600 vs Makita 5104!
- Makita 5007F vs 5007MG!
At-a-glance Specs: Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z
| Features | Makita XSH04ZB | Makita XSH03Z |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $149 ⭐ | $205 |
| Color | Black | Teal |
| Motor Power | Brushless (Same) | Brushless (Same) |
| Cutting Depth (90°) | 2-5/8" | 2-5/8" |
| Cutting Depth (45°) | 2-1/4" | 2-1/4" |
| Blade Size | 7-1/4" | 7-1/4" |
| Battery System | 18V X2 LXT | 18V X2 LXT |
| Weight | 6. 4 lbs | 6. 4 lbs |
| Electric Brake | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| LED Light | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Performance | Identical | Identical |
| Verdict | ✅ BEST VALUE | ❌ Overpriced |
| Where To Buy | Check On Amazon | Check On Amazon |
Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z: The Real Differences
Let’s cut through the marketing fluff and talk about what actually matters when you’re using these saws on the job.
What’s Actually Different Between These Models?
When I first compared the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z side by side, I was surprised how similar they really are. But there ARE some differences worth knowing about:
Model Designation & Release
- The XSH03Z is the older model
- The XSH04ZB is the newer revision with the “B” suffix (black edition)
- Both are part of Makita’s 18V X2 LXT series (meaning they use two batteries)
Color Finish
- XSH04ZB has a black body (that’s what the “B” stands for)
- XSH03Z comes in standard Makita teal
- Both feel identical in your hands
Price Point
- XSH04ZB: $149 on Amazon
- XSH03Z: $219 on Amazon
- That’s a $70 difference for basically the same tool
What’s EXACTLY The Same?
This is where it gets interesting. When comparing the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z, here’s what doesn’t change:
Motor Power
- Both have the same brushless motor
- Same cutting power and performance
- Same torque delivery
- You won’t feel any difference in cutting speed
Cutting Capacity
- Both cut 2-5/8″ at 90 degrees
- Both handle 2-1/4″ bevel cuts at 45 degrees
- Same 7-1/4″ blade size
- Identical cutting depth for framing work
Weight & Size
- Both weigh exactly the same
- Same ergonomic design
- Same grip comfort
- Identical balance when cutting
Battery System
- Both use Makita’s 18V X2 LXT system
- Both need two batteries to run
- Both are tool-only (batteries sold separately)
- Same battery life and runtime
Features
- Both have electric brake for safety
- Same LED work light
- Both include bevel capacity up to 53 degrees
- Identical dust blower to keep your cut line visible
Performance Comparison: How They Actually Cut?
Let’s talk about real-world use because that’s what matters.
Cutting Power & Speed
I’m going to be straight with you – when you’re ripping through 2x4s or cutting plywood, you cannot tell the difference between the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z. They have the same motor, same power output, same everything.
Both saws deliver:
- Clean, smooth cuts through dimensional lumber
- Enough power for all-day framing work
- No bogging down on dense materials
- Professional-grade cutting performance
Battery Life & Runtime
Since both the XSH04ZB and XSH03Z use the same dual 18V battery system, your runtime is identical. With two 5.0Ah batteries, expect:
- Around 120-150 cuts through 2×4 lumber
- Enough juice for a full day of light work
- Same charging time
- Same battery compatibility
Ease of Use & Handling
This is where both Makita circular saws really shine. The ergonomics are excellent on both models:
- Balanced weight distribution
- Comfortable grip for extended use
- Easy-to-reach trigger and safety
- Clear sight line to your cut mark
- Both feel like premium tools in your hands
The black edition (XSH04ZB) doesn’t handle any different than the teal XSH03Z. It’s purely cosmetic.
Build Quality & Durability
Makita doesn’t mess around with quality, and both these saws prove it.
Construction Quality
When comparing the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z for build quality:
- Both use the same die-cast magnesium base
- Same metal blade guards
- Identical internal components
- Both built to last years of professional use
Long-Term Reliability
Makita has a solid reputation, and these saws maintain it. Both models feature:
- Brushless motors (longer lifespan, less maintenance)
- Sealed bearings to keep dust out
- Durable housing that handles job site abuse
- Same 3-year warranty protection
There’s no difference in durability between these two models.
Safety Features Breakdown
Safety should never be an afterthought, so let’s look at what both saws offer:
Electric Brake Both the XSH04ZB and XSH03Z stop the blade quickly when you release the trigger. This is huge for preventing accidents.
Blade Guards Both have spring-loaded lower guards that snap back into place automatically. No fussing with manual guards.
Safety Lock Both require two-handed operation to start – you can’t accidentally trigger these saws.
Visibility Both include LED lights and dust blowers to keep your cut line visible.
When it comes to safety, the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z comparison is a complete tie.
Price & Value Analysis
Okay, this is where the rubber meets the road.
Current Pricing
- Makita XSH04ZB: $149
- Makita XSH03Z: $219
That $70 difference is significant. That’s almost enough to buy an extra battery or a nice blade upgrade.
What You’re Really Paying For?
When you choose the more expensive XSH03Z, you’re paying extra for:
- The teal color scheme
- An older model designation
- Absolutely nothing else in terms of performance
That’s it. That’s the list.
Value Winner
The Makita XSH04ZB destroys the XSH03Z in value. You’re getting the exact same saw for $70 less. Unless you’re a die-hard teal Makita collector, there’s no logical reason to spend more.
User Reviews & Real-World Feedback
Let’s see what actual users say about both models.
What Users Love?
People who own either the XSH04ZB or XSH03Z consistently praise:
- Incredible cutting power for a cordless saw
- Clean, accurate cuts every time
- Comfortable to use for extended periods
- Battery life that lasts through the workday
- Typical Makita reliability
Common Complaints
Both models share the same minor criticisms:
- Tool-only means you need to buy batteries separately
- Slightly heavier than single-battery saws (but that’s the trade-off for power)
- Price of Makita batteries if you don’t already own them
Overall Satisfaction
Both saws have excellent ratings. Users report professional-grade performance that justifies the investment in Makita’s ecosystem.
Pros & Cons Breakdown
Makita XSH04ZB Pros
✅ Best value at $149
✅ Same performance as the XSH03Z
✅ Sleek black finish looks professional
✅ Powerful brushless motor
✅ Excellent cutting capacity
✅ All-day battery life with 5.0Ah batteries
✅ Lightweight for a dual-battery saw
✅ Great ergonomics
Makita XSH04ZB Cons
❌ Tool-only (no batteries included)
❌ Requires two batteries to operate
❌ Heavier than single-battery models
Makita XSH03Z Pros
✅ Classic Makita teal color
✅ Proven track record
✅ Same great performance as XSH04ZB
✅ Professional-grade build quality
Makita XSH03Z Cons
❌ $70 more expensive
❌ No performance advantage over XSH04ZB
❌ Older model designation
❌ Tool-only (no batteries included)
Who Should Buy Each Model?
Buy the Makita XSH04ZB If:
- You want the best value
- You prefer black tools over teal
- You’re starting or expanding your Makita collection
- You want professional performance without overpaying
- You’re a contractor watching your tool budget
- You care more about performance than color
This is 95% of people.
Buy the Makita XSH03Z If:
- You absolutely must have the teal Makita color
- You found it on sale for less than the XSH04ZB
- You’re completing a teal Makita collection
- Color matters more to you than saving $70
This is maybe 5% of buyers.
Alternative Options Worth Considering
If you’re still on the fence about the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z debate, here are some alternatives:
If You Want Single Battery Operation:
- Makita XSH06Z (uses one 18V battery, less power but lighter)
- Milwaukee M18 Fuel Circular Saw
- DeWalt DCS573B
If You Want Corded Power:
- Makita 5007MG (corded, no battery concerns)
- Skilsaw SPT77WML-01
If Budget Is Tight:
- Ryobi P508 (much cheaper but less power)
- Craftsman CMCS500B
But honestly, if you’re already looking at the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z, you know you want quality. Neither of these alternatives offers better value than the XSH04ZB.
Tips for Getting the Most from Your Saw
Whichever model you choose, here’s how to maximize your investment:
Battery Strategy
- Buy at least two sets of batteries (four batteries total)
- Keep one set charging while using the other
- 5.0Ah or higher for best runtime
Blade Selection
- Use quality carbide-tipped blades
- Keep a finishing blade and a framing blade handy
- Replace dull blades immediately for safety
Maintenance
- Clean sawdust from the motor vents regularly
- Check blade guard operation before each use
- Store batteries at partial charge for longevity
- Keep the base plate clean and flat
Usage Tips
- Let the saw reach full speed before cutting
- Don’t force the cut – let the saw do the work
- Use a straight edge for long rip cuts
- Always wear safety glasses and ear protection
Final Verdict: Clear Winner Declared
After comparing every aspect of the Makita XSH04ZB vs XSH03Z, the winner is obvious:
🏆 The Makita XSH04ZB is the clear winner.
Here’s the bottom line: you’re getting identical performance, identical features, identical build quality, and identical cutting capacity for $70 less. The only difference is color, and that black finish actually looks more professional anyway.
Unless you’re a Makita purist who needs everything in teal, the XSH04ZB is the smarter buy. It’s not even a close call.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is the Makita XSH04ZB newer than the XSH03Z?
Yes, the XSH04ZB is the newer black edition revision of Makita’s dual 18V circular saw line.
Q: Does the XSH04ZB have more power than the XSH03Z?
No, they have identical motors and cutting performance. The power is exactly the same.
Q: Why is the XSH03Z more expensive?
The XSH03Z costs more primarily because of market positioning and the traditional Makita teal color. There’s no performance reason for the higher price.
Q: Can I use the same batteries for both saws?
Absolutely. Both the Makita XSH04ZB and XSH03Z use the same 18V LXT battery system.
Q: Which one is better for professional use?
Both are professional-grade tools. The XSH04ZB offers better value without sacrificing any performance.
Q: Do these saws come with batteries?
No, both are tool-only purchases. You’ll need to buy Makita 18V LXT batteries separately.
Q: What’s the cutting capacity difference?
There is no difference. Both cut 2-5/8″ at 90 degrees and 2-1/4″ at 45-degree bevels.
Q: Is the black finish more durable?
The finish color doesn’t affect durability. Both have the same protective coating and build quality.
