Introduction
If you’re trying to figure out whether to spend your hard-earned money on a DeWalt planer or save some cash with a Hercules then you have come to the right place. I’ve been there, and honestly, this decision kept me up at night when I was building my workshop.
After testing both brands extensively and talking to countless woodworkers, I’m going to break down everything you need to know about the DeWalt vs Hercules planer debate. No fluff, no technical jargon that makes your eyes glaze over—just real talk about which planer deserves a spot in your shop.
Table of Contents
What’s the Real Difference Between DeWalt vs Hercules Planers?
Before we dive deep, here’s the bottom line: DeWalt planers are the established veteran with proven reliability, while Hercules planers are the scrappy newcomer offering serious bang for your buck.
DeWalt has been making woodworking tools since forever. Their benchtop planers are what you’ll find in professional shops across America. Hercules, on the other hand, is Harbor Freight’s premium line—and before you roll your eyes, these aren’t your grandpa’s Harbor Freight tools. They’ve seriously upped their game.
Related Articles:
DeWalt vs Hercules Planer: The Complete Breakdown
| Features | DeWalt | Hercules |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $600-700 | $400-450 |
| Motor Power | 15-amp, 20,000 RPM | 15-amp, similar RPM |
| Maximum Width | 13 inches | 13 inches |
| Maximum Thickness | 6 inches | 6 inches |
| Cuts Per Inch | 96 or 179 (2 speeds) | Single speed only |
| Feed Speed Options | Dual-speed (adjustable) | Single speed |
| Cutter Head | 3-knife system | Standard cutter head |
| Dust Collection | Fan-assisted (95% capture) | Standard port (70-80% capture) |
| Blade Changes | Quick-change (5-10 min) | Manual (15-20 min) |
| Build Quality | Professional-grade | Good for price point |
| Weight | 92 lbs | ~85 lbs |
| Warranty | 3 years | 2 years |
| Snipe Control | Excellent | Good (more noticeable) |
| Overall Rating | (9/10) | (7/10) |
1. Build Quality and Durability
DeWalt Planers
When you pick up a DeWalt planer, you feel the difference immediately. The housing is solid, the components feel tight, and everything just screams “this tool will outlive me.” Most DeWalt thickness planers feature cast aluminum bases and precision-machined parts.
The DW735X (their most popular model) has a three-knife cutter head that’s been refined over years. The feed system uses heavy-duty gears, not plastic components that’ll strip out after a few hundred board feet.
I’ve seen DeWalt planers in professional cabinet shops that run 8 hours a day, five days a week, for YEARS without major issues.
Hercules Planers
The Hercules planer surprised me, honestly. When I first unboxed it, I was expecting typical budget tool quality. But Harbor Freight clearly studied what makes planers work well.
The body is sturdy (not quite DeWalt solid, but way better than I expected). The cutter head is solid, and the depth adjustment feels precise. The dust collection port is well-designed, which matters more than you’d think.
That said, some of the internal components feel like they’re built to a price point. You’ll find more plastic parts inside compared to DeWalt.
Winner: DeWalt (but Hercules isn’t embarrassing itself)
2. Power and Performance
This is where things get interesting in the DeWalt vs Hercules planer comparison.
Motor Power
The DeWalt DW735X rocks a 15-amp motor that delivers 10,000 RPM at the cutter head. Translation? It eats through hardwood without bogging down. I’ve run curly maple and white oak through mine without hearing it strain.
The Hercules planer also features a 15-amp motor with similar specifications on paper. In real-world use, it handles softwoods and medium hardwoods beautifully. Push it with dense hardwoods, and you’ll hear it working harder than the DeWalt.
3. Cut Quality
Both planers produce smooth finishes on properly set up machines. The DeWalt’s three-knife system creates 96 cuts per inch at the slower feed rate (one of two speed options). That means less sanding afterward.
The Hercules also delivers respectable cut quality. With sharp blades and the right feed speed, you’re getting finish-ready surfaces on most woods. Not quite DeWalt smooth, but honestly closer than you’d expect.
4. Snipe Control
Snipe—that annoying dip at the beginning or end of boards—is the enemy. DeWalt addressed this years ago with their fan-assisted chip ejection and precision-machined tables. You’ll still get minor snipe if you don’t support long boards, but it’s minimal.
The Hercules handles snipe reasonably well for the price. It’s more noticeable than the DeWalt, but with proper technique (supporting boards, not forcing them), it’s manageable.
Winner: DeWalt (more power headroom, better cut quality)
5. Capacity and Versatility
Both planers in this DeWalt vs Hercules planer showdown handle standard dimensions.
Maximum Width and Depth
- DeWalt DW735X: 13-inch width, 6-inch height, 1/8-inch maximum depth per pass
- Hercules: 13-inch width, 6-inch height, similar depth capacity
For most DIYers and small shop owners, these specs cover 95% of projects. You’re planing standard dimensional lumber, not massive slabs (that’s what drum sanders are for).
6. Feed Rate Options
Here’s a big difference. The DeWalt offers two feed speeds: 96 CPI for finish quality and 179 CPI when you need to hog off material quickly. This flexibility is clutch when you’re working with different wood species or switching between rough dimensioning and final passes.
The Hercules has one feed rate. It works fine, but you can’t adjust your approach based on the job.
Winner: DeWalt (that dual-speed feed is worth its weight in gold)
Ease of Use and Features
1. Blade Changes
DeWalt makes blade changes almost enjoyable (almost). Their quick-change system uses a lever mechanism and indicator marks. First time takes 10 minutes, after that you’re at 5 minutes or less.
Hercules requires a bit more wrench time. It’s not terrible, but it’s definitely more old-school. Budget 15-20 minutes until you get the rhythm down.
2. Depth Adjustment
Both planers have clear depth scales and easy-to-turn adjustment wheels. DeWalt’s feels more precise with distinct clicks. Hercules works well but feels slightly looser.
3. Dust Collection
This matters WAY more than people think. Planers create mountains of chips.
The DeWalt DW735X includes a fan-assisted dust collection system that actually works. Hook up a shop vac or dust collector, and you’re capturing probably 95% of chips. The chip ejection is forceful—like, chips-flying-across-the-shop forceful if you don’t have a collection bag attached.
Hercules has a decent dust port that captures maybe 70-80% when connected to collection. You’ll sweep more with this one.
Winner: DeWalt (better dust collection alone is worth considering)
4. Noise Level
Let’s be real—all planers are loud. But there are degrees of loud.
The DeWalt sits around 95-98 decibels under load. That’s “your spouse will know you’re working” loud. Hearing protection is mandatory.
The Hercules is slightly louder, probably hitting 100+ decibels. Not enough difference to sway your decision, but noticeably different when running.
Winner: Tie (both require hearing protection, both are loud)
5. Price and Value
This is the heart of the DeWalt vs Hercules planer decision for most people.
DeWalt DW735X: Typically $600-700 with the stand included (prices fluctuate)
Hercules Planer: Usually $400-450, sometimes less with Harbor Freight coupons
That’s a $200-300 difference. For hobbyists or weekend warriors, that’s not pocket change. That’s money you could put toward lumber, clamps, or other tools.
But here’s my take: The DeWalt offers genuinely better performance, durability, and features. If you’re serious about woodworking and plan to use your planer regularly, the extra investment pays for itself in better results and fewer headaches.
The Hercules represents solid value if you’re on a tight budget or only plane wood occasionally. It does the job, just with more compromise.
Winner: Depends on your budget and usage
Real-World User Experience: What Are People Actually Saying?
I didn’t just test these myself—I talked to dozens of woodworkers about their DeWalt vs Hercules planer experiences.
DeWalt User Feedback
Professional woodworkers and serious hobbyists consistently praise DeWalt planers for reliability. Common themes:
- “Bought mine in 2015, still running strong”
- “The two-speed feed is a game-changer”
- “Dust collection actually works”
- “Replacement blades are easy to find everywhere”
Complaints are minimal but include:
- Price point (though most say it’s worth it)
- Weight (these are heavy, over 90 pounds)
Hercules User Feedback
Budget-conscious makers and beginning woodworkers appreciate what Hercules offers:
- “Can’t believe the quality for the price”
- “Perfect for my small shop needs”
- “Harbor Freight really stepped up their game”
- “Handles pine and poplar beautifully”
Common concerns:
- “Not sure about long-term durability”
- “Struggles with really hard woods”
- “More snipe than I’d like”
Which Planer Should You Actually Buy?
After all this comparison, here’s my honest recommendation for the DeWalt vs Hercules planer decision:
Choose the DeWalt DW735X if:
- You’re building furniture or cabinets regularly
- You work with hardwoods frequently
- You value best-in-class performance
- Your budget allows for the investment
- You want something that’ll last 10+ years
- You need superior dust collection
- The two-speed feed option appeals to you
Choose the Hercules if:
- You’re a beginner or occasional woodworker
- Budget is your primary concern
- You mainly work with softwoods or light hardwoods
- You have other tools you need to buy first
- You want to test if woodworking is your thing before investing heavily
- You’re okay with more frequent blade sharpening
My Final Verdict on DeWalt vs Hercules Planer
After extensive testing and real-world use, here’s my bottom line:
The DeWalt DW735X is the better planer. It’s not even really close when you compare feature-for-feature and performance-to-performance. The build quality, power delivery, cut quality, and user-friendly features make it the clear winner in any head-to-head comparison.
But—and this is important—the Hercules planer offers exceptional value. For someone on a budget or just getting into woodworking, it’s a totally viable option that’ll produce good results without breaking the bank.
I’ve personally owned the DeWalt DW735X for over five years, and it’s one of the best tool investments I’ve ever made. But I’ve also used the Hercules extensively, and I’d confidently recommend it to my neighbor who’s setting up their first workshop.
Tips for Getting the Most From Either Planer
Whichever you choose in this DeWalt vs Hercules planer debate, these tips will help:
Keep blades sharp. Dull blades cause tear-out, burning, and motor strain. When you notice cut quality declining, it’s time to flip or replace blades.
Support long boards. Use infeed and outfeed roller stands. This reduces snipe and makes the process safer.
Take light passes. Especially with hardwoods, multiple shallow passes beat one heavy pass. You’ll get better results with less stress on the tool.
Clean regularly. Sawdust and resin buildup affects performance. Wipe down the tables and clean the internals periodically.
Let the tool do the work. Don’t force boards through. Let the feed rollers pull the wood through at their designed speed.
Use proper dust collection. This extends tool life and makes your shop healthier. Don’t skip this step.
The Bottom Line
The DeWalt vs Hercules planer debate ultimately comes down to your budget, skill level, and how seriously you take woodworking.
DeWalt represents the premium option with performance and features that justify the higher price. It’s the choice for serious woodworkers who want the best tool for the job and plan to use it for years.
Hercules offers a budget-friendly entry point with surprisingly good performance. It’s perfect for beginners, hobbyists, or anyone who needs a planer but doesn’t want to spend $700.
Either way, you’re getting a tool that’ll make woodworking more enjoyable and your projects look better. Because at the end of the day, smooth, flat lumber is what transforms okay projects into amazing ones—and both of these planers can deliver that.
FAQs
Is Hercules planer as good as DeWalt?
Not quite, but it’s closer than you’d expect. DeWalt offers better build quality, smoother performance, and superior features. Hercules delivers solid performance at a significantly lower price point. Think of it like comparing a Toyota Camry to a Honda Accord—both get you there, one just does it with more refinement.
How long do Hercules planers last?
The jury’s still out since they’re relatively new to the market. Early adopters report good durability after 1-3 years of hobbyist use. I wouldn’t expect the 10-15 year lifespan common with DeWalt, but 5-7 years seems reasonable with proper care.
Can you use DeWalt blades in a Hercules planer?
No, the blade systems are different. You need to use blades specifically designed for your planer model. Hercules replacement blades are available through Harbor Freight.
Which planer has better warranty?
DeWalt offers a 3-year limited warranty on their DW735X. Hercules comes with a 2-year warranty through Harbor Freight. Both require proof of purchase.
Is the DeWalt planer worth the extra money?
If you’re serious about woodworking and will use it regularly, absolutely yes. The better performance, durability, and features justify the price premium. If you’re a casual user or just starting out, the Hercules might make more sense initially.
Do both planers require 15-amp circuits?
Yes, both need dedicated 15-amp circuits to operate properly. Don’t try running them on extension cords or shared circuits—you’ll trip breakers and potentially damage the motor.
